How Google Decides Who to Show First

~18 min read

Every day, thousands of people in Ireland open Google and type "hairdresser near me", "boiler repair Dublin" or "best pizza in Cork". A couple of seconds later they see a list of businesses, and they almost always pick one of the first few. Why do some businesses end up at the top while others sit on page two, where nobody looks? The answer is SEO.

What is SEO

SEO (search engine optimisation) is the work you do on your website and on your business's information online so that Google shows you above your competitors. Not for money, the way ads work, but because Google considers your website the best answer to the person's question.

Think of Google as a huge library with a very picky librarian. You ask: "Where can I get my bike repaired in Galway?" The librarian won't bring you every book. They'll pick the few that fit best and that they trust. SEO is how you make sure the librarian knows about your "book", understands what it's about and trusts it.

How Google search works

It happens in three steps:

  1. Crawling. Special Google programs, called "bots" or "crawlers", constantly travel around the internet reading websites, like a courier who visits every street in a city.
  2. Indexing. Google files everything it has read on shelves: this site is about dentistry in Cork, that one is about flower delivery in Dublin. If your site isn't in this catalogue, nobody will find it at all.
  3. Ranking. When someone types a query, Google picks the most relevant pages from the catalogue in a fraction of a second and puts them in order. The ones it trusts most go at the top.

The job of SEO is to help your website at each of these steps: so the bot finds it easily, understands it correctly and ranks it higher.

What is local SEO

Local SEO is promotion where your customers live. When someone searches "electrician near me" or "café in Limerick", Google shows a map and three businesses beneath it. Getting into that top three is like hanging your sign on the busiest street in town: this is where people call, get directions and walk in.

In Ireland this matters even more. Most services, from plumbing to beauty salons, are searched for close to home. A customer in Drogheda doesn't need a tradesperson from Kilkenny, even the best one.

How Google decides who to rank higher

Google doesn't say exactly how it chooses who to show first. But it has explained the main rules itself. Put simply, Google asks five questions about every website. Let's go through them using a Dublin plumber as an example.

1. Do you offer what the person is looking for?

People describe the same problem in different ways. One types "leaking tap", another "emergency plumber", a third "plumber near me". Google understands that all three need a plumber.

But how does Google know the plumber is you? Only from the text on your website. If it only says "installation of engineering systems", Google may not realise you fix taps. And someone searching "leaking tap" won't be shown your site.

What to do: write on your site the way customers speak. Not "rectification of leaks in shut-off valves" but "we'll fix your tap if it's leaking". List in everyday words everything you do: tap repairs, boiler replacement, drain unblocking. Then Google will connect your site with all of those searches.

2. Is there a full answer on the site?

Say Google has found twenty plumbers' websites in Dublin. Which one should it show first? The one where the person finds everything they need to know before they call.

And what does someone with a leaking tap need to know? Whether you do exactly this. Whether you cover their area. Roughly what it costs. Whether you can come today or at the weekend.

Compare two websites. The first has one line: "Plumbing services. Call us." The second has a list of services, the areas you cover, approximate prices, opening hours, photos of finished jobs and answers to common questions. Google will show the second one higher because it's more useful to the person.

3. Can you be trusted?

Google doesn't want to send people to scammers. So it checks whether your site looks like the website of a real, reliable business.

What helps: a real address and phone number, a story about who you are and how long you've been working, photos of your work, customer reviews.

What others say about you matters even more. When other websites link to yours, Google sees it as a recommendation. For example, a local newspaper wrote about your company and linked to your site. Or a trade association listed you among its members. The better known the site that links to you, the more Google trusts you.

4. Is your website easy to use?

People most often search for a plumber on their phone, right at the moment water is leaking. If your site loads slowly, or you can't make out anything on a small screen, the person will close it and go to a competitor. Google takes this into account.

But ease of use is a bonus, not the main thing. A fast site without the information people need will still lose to a slower but more useful one. Ease of use decides things when sites are about equally good in content.

A simple check: open your site on your phone. Did it load quickly? Can you find the phone number and call within a couple of seconds?

5. Where is the person searching from?

The same search gives different results to different people. The main factor is where the person is. Someone in Cork searching "plumber" will see plumbers in Cork; someone in Dublin will see Dublin tradespeople. What the person has searched for before and what language they use for search also play a part.

So your site should say clearly which town and which areas you work in. Otherwise Google won't know which city's residents to show you to.

What makes a good website in Google's eyes

Now that it's clear what questions Google asks about every site, let's look at SEO through a specialist's eyes. Work on a website is usually divided into five areas. Each has its own name, and you'll certainly hear them if you talk to an SEO agency.

Semantic core: which searches should find you

The semantic core is a list of all the search queries that should lead customers to you. For a Dublin plumber it will contain hundreds of phrases: "plumber Dublin", "boiler repair", "leaking tap what to do", "plumber Dublin 6" and so on.

Every serious piece of work on a site starts with this list. A specialist collects queries using special tools, looks at how often people type them, and groups them by meaning. Each group gets its own page on the site: a separate page on boiler repair, another on blocked drains, another on emergency call-outs. That way the site answers Google's question "do you offer what the person is looking for?" not with one general phrase but service by service.

An important consequence: the whole semantic core can't fit on one page. One page can answer well on only one topic, such as boiler repair. If you add blocked drains, shower installation and emergency call-outs to it, Google won't understand what it's really about and won't show it high for any of those searches.

That is exactly why a landing page, a one-page site listing all your services at once, is so hard to promote. It can work well for ads, but in ordinary search it has one page for hundreds of different queries, and for most of them it will lose to sites with separate pages.

The ideal is a page for each service or product. And sometimes several pages for one service if it's too broad. For example, "boiler repair" can be split into gas and electric boilers, or into popular brands, if people search for them separately.

Without a semantic core a site is built blindly: it's about what seems important to the owner, not what customers search for.

Content: what is written and shown on the site

Content is everything on the site: text, photos, video, prices, answers to questions. The semantic core suggests what to write about. Content is what the person actually reads and sees. It's what Google uses to decide whether the site has a full answer and whether you can be trusted.

What good content looks like:

  • Complete. A boiler repair page explains which faults you fix, what it costs, how long it takes and what to do before the engineer arrives. The person doesn't have to look for answers elsewhere.
  • Written for people. Google says directly that it values helpful content made for people, not for search rankings. Text stuffed with keywords works against you.
  • Based on your experience. Photos of your work, examples from practice, specific cases. A competitor who rewrote someone else's text doesn't have these, and Google specifically values first-hand experience.
  • Unique. Text copied from another site adds nothing: that information already exists online, and Google has no reason to show it again.
  • Up to date. Out-of-date prices, expired offers and old phone numbers undermine the trust of people and Google alike.

Without good content neither clean code nor links will work: if there is nothing for the person to read, there's no reason for them to stay on the site.

Internal SEO: order on the site itself

Internal SEO (on-page SEO) is everything done on the site itself so that Google can read it easily and understand it correctly.

The key thing to understand: Google doesn't see a website the way a person does. A person looks at pictures, colours and buttons. Google reads the code, the text of instructions the browser uses to build the page. If the code is a tangle, Google may not understand what's most important on the page, even if the site looks great.

So the foundation of internal SEO is clean, properly written code. Here is what it consists of:

  • Correct HTML tags. HTML is the language a page is written in. It has special markers (tags) that tell Google what is what: this is the main heading, this is a subheading, this is a list, this is the menu. If a heading is simply set in large type without the proper tag, a person sees a heading, but Google sees ordinary text.
  • A title and description for every page. In the code, each page has a title and a short description (meta description). These are what a person often sees in search results. Every page must have its own, saying exactly what it's about.
  • Text formatting. Text is broken into paragraphs, subheadings and lists. Text like that is easy for both people and Google to read. A solid wall of text loses.
  • Internal linking. Pages of the site link to each other: from the home page you can reach all services, from "boiler repair" you can go to "emergency call-out". This way Google finds all the pages and understands how they're connected and which matter more, and people don't get lost on the site.
  • Image descriptions. So Google understands exactly what is in a photo, a short caption (the alt attribute) is added in the code, for example "gas boiler replacement in Dublin 4".
  • Business data markup. This is special code that tells Google directly: here is the company name, here are the address, phone number and opening hours. That way Google doesn't have to guess.
  • Speed. Excess, heavy code slows a site down. The cleaner the code, the faster the page opens, especially on a phone.
  • No errors. Broken links and "404" error pages annoy people, while identical duplicate pages confuse Google: it doesn't know which one to show.

All of this directly affects behavioural factors, the way people behave once they reach a site (more on these below). If a page loads slowly, the text is a solid wall and the service can't be found through the menu, the person will close it and go back to search. But if the site opens instantly, the text is easy to read and internal links lead to the next useful page, the person stays, reads and calls. In other words, good internal SEO helps twice: Google understands the site better, and people stay on it longer.

To put it simply: a good website, to Google, is good code. Clean, tidy, logically organised and easy to make sense of. Beautiful design matters to people, but if tangled code is hiding behind it, Google simply won't see what the site has to offer.

Internal SEO answers Google's questions "is there a full answer on the site?" and "is the site easy to use?".

Why sites built on website builders and cheap templates lose out

Website builders and ready-made templates are attractive for their simplicity: choose a design, paste in some text, and by evening the site is ready. For a start, that can be a sensible solution. But when it comes to fighting for the first lines of search results, such sites quickly hit a ceiling. And the reason is exactly what we discussed above: the code.

  • Excess code. A builder is designed to do everything at once: online shop, blog, portfolio, gallery. So the code of every page includes a lot your site doesn't need. The page gets heavier and opens more slowly, especially on a phone.
  • Little control. On a builder you can change only what the platform allows. How headings are marked up, how pages link to each other, what's in the code: often it isn't you who decides. Sometimes what is getting in Google's way simply can't be fixed.
  • Identical sites. A cheap template is used by hundreds of other businesses, often together with ready-made placeholder text. To a person, such a site feels faceless, and Google finds nothing in it that isn't already on other sites.
  • Hard to grow. Remember the separate page for every service? A template is usually designed for a few standard pages: Home, About, Services, Contact. When you need dozens of pages with a clear structure and internal linking, the template starts to get in the way.
  • Tied to the platform. A site on a builder can't simply be taken and moved. If you decide to change platform, the site often has to be rebuilt from scratch, and a move carries the risk of losing the search positions you've already earned.

The bottom line is simple: a builder is fine for getting online quickly. But if your competitors invest in SEO and you want to beat them in search, you'll need a website built for your business and fully under your control.

External SEO: reputation beyond the site

External SEO (off-page SEO) is work on what is said about you in the rest of the internet. First of all, these are links to your site from other resources: local news sites, industry directories, partners' websites. It also includes customer reviews and mentions of your company.

What matters here is quality, not quantity. One link from a well-known Irish newspaper weighs more than a hundred links from unknown sites.

Good links rarely appear on their own. Here is where they usually come from:

  • Sites that link to competitors. Special tools show which sites link to the businesses at the top of search. Often this is a ready-made list of places your site could appear too: an industry directory, a trade association, a local portal.
  • Directories and listings. Reliable Irish business directories and industry listings. The name, address and phone number in them must match those on your site so that neither customers nor Google get confused.
  • Coverage of your business. An expert article on an industry site, a comment for a local paper, sponsorship of a city event. Each such piece is a link, and at the same time visibility and trust.
  • Partners. Suppliers, builders and other companies you work with can mention you on their sites. For Google these are natural links: you really are connected to each other.
  • Reviews. The more happy customers leave reviews, the better your reputation. And it's important to reply to every one, including negative ones.

The reverse can happen too: lots of junk sites link to yours, for example after the work of an unscrupulous contractor. In that case you can ask Google to ignore those links.

One more thing: external SEO is a long game. Reputation builds up over months, just as in life: you can't become a well-known and respected company in your town in a week.

External SEO answers Google's question "can you be trusted?".

Behavioural factors: how visitors behave

Behavioural factors are how people behave when they find your site in search. Do they click through from the results? Do they stay and read? Or do they go back after five seconds and pick a competitor?

Google itself says it uses anonymised data about how people interact with search results to work out which pages are really useful. The logic is simple: if people leave a site again and again and keep searching, they probably didn't find an answer there.

Exactly what is counted and how, Google doesn't disclose. But the idea is always the same: did the person find what they were looking for? People usually talk about three things:

  • Whether people choose you in the results. Before clicking, a person sees the page title and a short description. If they are clear and promise an answer, people click on you more often than on your neighbours.
  • Whether people go back. A person lands on a site and a few seconds later returns to the results to open another. Most likely they didn't find an answer.
  • Whether the search ends with you. The best outcome: the person comes to you, reads, calls or leaves an enquiry, and searches no more.

An example. A customer searches "emergency plumber Dublin" and opens two sites. On the first, they immediately see "We'll be there within an hour" and a Call button. The second takes ages to load and then begins with the history of the company. From the first the person calls, from the second they leave. When this happens again and again, Google accumulates data on which site is more useful.

Everything discussed above affects people's behaviour: clear page titles and descriptions, an answer on the first screen, useful content, fast loading, a mobile-friendly version and visible contact details.

Summary

A good website in Google's eyes is one that helps a person solve their problem better than the others. The five areas of SEO work only together:

  • the semantic core determines what the site should be about;
  • content gives the person a full and useful answer;
  • internal SEO makes sure Google understands it and the person finds it easy to use;
  • external SEO confirms that you can be trusted;
  • behavioural factors show that people find on the site what they were looking for.

If even one area fails, the whole result suffers. Good text won't help if the site doesn't open on a phone. And a hundred links won't save a page that doesn't answer the person's question.

SEO or ads: which to choose

You can also reach the top of Google for money, through Google Ads. The simplest way to explain the difference: ads are renting, SEO is buying.

Ads work immediately: set up a campaign and today your ad is at the top. But you pay for every click: someone clicked the ad and went to your site, and the money was charged. Whether they called afterwards or closed the site a second later doesn't matter: the click is already paid for. And as soon as the ad budget runs out, the ads disappear, and with them the flow of customers.

SEO works more slowly: the first noticeable results usually appear after a few months. But then customers come without payment for each click, and people tend to trust ordinary, non-ad results more.

The main difference is in what you end up with. Ads give you a place in the ad block for as long as you pay, and the site itself doesn't rise in ordinary search results because of it. The result of SEO is exactly that: your site rises in ordinary results for the searches that matter to your business. That place isn't rented, it's earned: Google puts you higher because it considers your site the best answer. And it lasts as long as your site stays better than your competitors'.

What to choose:

  • you need customers right now: start with ads;
  • you plan to work for the long term and don't want to pay for every customer for ever: invest in SEO;
  • the best option for most businesses is to combine them: ads bring customers today, SEO brings a steady flow tomorrow.

The main point

SEO is not magic and it's not tricking algorithms. It's work to make Google understand that your business is the best answer for the person searching for you right now. The clearer, easier to use and more reliable you look online, the more often customers find you.

Want to find out why your business isn't yet in the Google Maps top three? Order an SEO audit: we'll explain in plain language what's holding you back and what to fix first.

Hi! How can we help?

Usually reply within a few hours during business hours